Vanessa M. – Oct. 5 – The defendant was charged with driving over the legal limit for alcohol, dangerous driving and the Highway Traffic Act charge of stunt driving-driving more than 40 kms above the speed limit. The matter went to trial. Both criminal charges were dismissed by the trial judge. I convinced the judge that the evidence of driving was restricted to excessive speed and did not reach the level required to convict on the criminal charge of dangerous driving. I also convinced the trial judge that the defendant’s right to counsel was infringed in these circumstances where she expressed dissatisfaction with the advice she received from the Legal Aid lawyer she spoke to, but nothing was done by police to address her dissatisfaction. As a result, the trial judge excluded the defendant’s breath readings from evidence and dismissed the drive over the legal limit charge as well. Unfortunately, the defendant was convicted of the Highway Traffic Act charge of stunt driving which carries with it an automatic one-year driver’s licence suspension but the defendant avoided a criminal record.
Shaun C. – Oct 6 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving, driving over the legal limit for alcohol and driving while disqualified. The matter went to trial. All three criminal charges were dismissed. I convinced the trial judge that there was insufficient evidence led in the prosecutor’s case to justify a conviction on the impaired driving and driving while disqualified charges. I also convinced the trial judge that the defendant’s right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure and unlawful detention were infringed and that the infringements were serious enough to justify the exclusion of the breath readings from the breath samples provided by the defendant. This resulted in the dismissal of the driving over the legal limit charge as there was no other evidence establishing the defendant’s blood alcohol concentration on this occasion.
Michael C. – Oct 27 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit for alcohol. The matter went to trial. After I finished cross-examining the first prosecution witness, the prosecutor determined that the identity of the defendant as the driver of the vehicle in question could not be proven. The prosecutor invited the judge to dismiss both charges. The judge dismissed both charges.
Robert S. – Oct. 27 – The defendant was charged with drive disqualified, flight from police, and possession of property obtained by crime. The defendant had multiple prior convictions for driving while disqualified, and the prosecutor was initially seeking a lengthy jail sentence. The matter was scheduled for trial. After discussions with the prosecutor on the morning of trial the prosecutor agreed to a resolution where the defendant plead guilty to Highway Traffic Act offences of drive suspended and careless driving for the minimum fines and licence suspensions. After the plea was entered, the criminal charges were withdrawn.
John V. – Sept 25 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving, driving over the legal limit for alcohol and driving while disqualified. The defendant had previous convictions for drinking and driving and would have faced a presumptive lifetime driving ban had he been convicted of either the impaired or over the limit charge. The trial began but did not conclude on the first date set for trial. Before the matter could proceed to the second date for trial, the arresting officer became unavailable to return to court and it was unclear how long he would be unavailable. As a result, a resolution was reached whereby the defendant was permitted to plead guilty to driving while disqualified. This reduced the driving suspension down from a potential lifetime ban to one year. The defendant was also required to pay a fine. Once the defendant entered his plea to driving while disqualified the impaired and driving over the legal limit charges were withdrawn by the prosecution.
Mark B. – Sept 29 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit of alcohol. Both charges were dismissed by the judge after a trial. I was able to convince the judge that the breath readings should not be admissible at the trial because of infringements of the defendant’s right to counsel. This exclusion of the breath readings resulted in there being no evidence upon which the over the limit charge could be proven. I also convinced the judge that the evidence of impairment was too thin to convict on the impaired driving charge.
Clements T. – Aug 28 – The defendant was charged with 80 plus. The defendant had no criminal record and his readings were relatively low. Counsel was able to negotiate a resolution where the defendant pled guilty to careless driving under the Highway Traffic Act. After the plea was entered, the criminal charge was withdrawn.
Michael V. – Aug 20 -The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit of alcohol. Prior to trial, the prosecutor offered a resolution that was accepted by the defendant. The defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a period of probation where he was required to drive with an ignition interlock installed in his vehicle. After he pled guilty to careless driving, the prosecutor withdrew both criminal charges.
John E. – July 27 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and dangerous driving. The defendant was involved in a motor vehicle accident with a second vehicle. When police investigated, they believed the defendant was impaired by alcohol or drugs or both. He was taken to a police station where a drug recognition evaluator (a police officer trained to find evidence of impairment by narcotics) did tests on the defendant which led this officer to conclude that the defendant was impaired by drug, and he was charged with the above two offences. Medical evidence was obtained and provided to the prosecution proving that, in fact, the defendant had suffered a stroke while driving and wasn’t impaired by drugs at all. As a result of this evidence, the prosecution withdrew both charges against the defendant.
Jason W. – July 17 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit of alcohol. Prior to trial, the prosecutor offered a resolution that was accepted by the defendant. The defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a period of probation and no suspension of his driving privileges. After he pled guilty to careless driving, the prosecutor withdrew both criminal charges.
Henry R. – July 6 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving, driving over the legal limit for alcohol and dangerous driving. On the first date set for trial the matter could not be reached due to an overly busy court docket. The matter was rescheduled to a date that was arguably outside the constitutionally mandated period in which criminal trials must be dealt with. I served a motion to have the charges thrown out because of this. Before the motion was heard, the prosecution offer the defendant a plea bargain that he accepted. Rather than proceeding on the criminal charges, the prosecution allowed the defendant to plead guilty to the non-criminal charge of careless driving under the Highway Traffic Act for a fine and a period of time wherein he would have to drive with an ignition interlock in his vehicle. Once the defendant pled guilty to careless driving, all three criminal charges were withdrawn by the prosecutor.
Beant K. – May 4 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit of alcohol. Prior to trial, the prosecutor offered a resolution that was accepted by the defendant. The defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a period of probation where he was required to drive with an ignition interlock installed in his vehicle. After he pled guilty to careless driving, the prosecutor withdrew both criminal charges.
Brett P. – April 29 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit of alcohol. Prior to trial, the prosecutor offered a resolution that was accepted by the defendant. The defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and no driving suspension. After he pled guilty to careless driving, the prosecutor withdrew both criminal charges.
Yusuf S. – April 23 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving, driving over the legal limit for alcohol and driving while disqualified. The matter went to trial. Partway through the trial, it became apparent to the prosecutor that there was insufficient evidence to prove that the defendant drove the vehicle in question on the date he was charged. As such, the prosecutor invited the judge to dismiss all three charges. The judge dismissed all three charges.
Ashley M. – April 22 – The defendant was charged with driving over the legal limit for alcohol. The matter proceeded to trial. I argued that the police infringed the defendant’s right to counsel at two different junctures during the investigation. Once all the evidence had been led by the prosecutor at trial, he conceded that the evidence did indeed show that the defendant’s right to counsel had been violated by the police. The prosecutor invited the judge to dismiss the charge. The trial judge dismissed the charge.
Michael B. – April 8 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit for alcohol after he caused a motor vehicle accident. His readings were just above the legal limit and although he had a previous conviction for drinking and driving, it was very dated. There was a concern by the prosecution that the matter could not be tried with the time frame required by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (within 18 months of the charges being laid) so a resolution was reached. The defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the non-criminal traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a period of time where he had to drive with an ignition interlock device in his car. Once the plea was entered both criminal charges were withdrawn.
Shaun J. – March 27 – The defendant was charged with driving over the legal limit for alcohol. The charge was dismissed after trial. I was able to convince the trial judge that the prosecution had not proven the accuracy of the breath readings beyond a reasonable doubt, the standard of proof in all criminal trials.
Kirat S. – March 19 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit for alcohol. On the date set for trial, the matter could not proceed as the arresting officer was testifying in another matter in another jurisdiction. On the second date set for trial the matter could also not be reached because of other matters on the list that had higher priority. Rather than adjourn the matter to a third trial and run the risk that the matter might go beyond the period within which trials are constitutionally-mandated to conclude, the prosecution agreed to a resolution. The defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the non-criminal traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a period of 1 year where he was required to drive with an ignition interlock device in his vehicle. After the defendant pled guilty to careless driving, both criminal charges were withdrawn.
Richard F. – March 18 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving over the legal limit for alcohol. On the date set for trial, the matter could not proceed as the trial judge was ill that day. Rather than adjourn the matter and run the risk that the matter might go beyond the period within which trials are constitutionally-mandated to conclude, the prosecution agreed to a resolution. The defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the non-criminal traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a period of 6 months when his driving privileges were limited to work purposes and some other exceptions. After the defendant pled guilty to careless driving, both criminal charges were withdrawn.
Wayne E. – March 16 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving, driving over the legal limit for alcohol and dangerous driving. The matter proceeded to trial. Partway through the trial, I was able to convince the prosecutor that the only evidence establishing that the defendant was the driver of the vehicle in question was vulnerable to exclusion based on a constitutional infringement of the defendant’s right to counsel. As a result, the defendant was allowed to plead guilty to the non-criminal traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a requirement that he drive with an ignition interlock device in his car for a period of time. Once the defendant was sentenced on the traffic charge, all three criminal charges were withdrawn.
Mazen B. – March 13 – The defendant was charged with refusing to provide a breath sample. The matter proceeded to trial. I was able to convince the trial judge that the prosecutor had not proven that a lawful breath demand had been made to the defendant prior to his refusal to provide a breath sample. The trial judge dismissed the charge
Arie G. – March-11 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving and driving above the legal limit for alcohol. The breath readings were only slightly above the legal limit and I was prepared to argue at trial that the defendant’s right to consult with his counsel of choice had been infringed. A resolution was reached whereby the defendant was allowed to plead
guilty to the non-criminal traffic offence of careless driving for a fine and a requirement that he drive with an ignition interlock device in his car for a period of time. Once the defendant was sentenced on the traffic charge, both criminal charges were withdrawn.
Hossein M. – Jan 14 – The defendant was charged with impaired driving, driving over the legal limit of alcohol and failing to remain after an accident, a non-criminal charge under the Highway Traffic Act. I was able to convince the prosecutor that the defendant’s constitutional rights were infringed in many respects which could cause the prosecution serious difficulties in proving the criminal charges. As a result, a resolution was reached whereby the defendant pled guilty to the failing to remain charge. He received a $400 fine with no suspension of his driving privileges. Once the guilty plea was entered to the traffic offence, the two criminal charges were withdrawn.
Samantha L.-Jan 6 – The defendant was charged with driving over the legal limit for alcohol and driving while using a cell phone. Both charges were dismissed after a trial. I convinced the judge that the defendant’s right to be free from unlawful detention and unlawful search or seizure was infringed as the arresting officer did not have sufficient grounds to arrest the defendant in the first place. I also convinced the judge that the infringement was serious enough that it justified the exclusion from evidence of the breath readings (which were above the legal limit). As regards the cell phone charge, the prosecutor neglected to proceed on the charge and ultimately withdrew the charge.
